What Are Thresholds In Dog Training?

You are currently viewing What Are Thresholds In Dog Training?

Have you ever watched your dog go from calm and attentive in one moment, to barking, lunging, jumping, or completely ignoring you in a matter of seconds? This is a common occurrence and as a dog owner, you may be wondering what happened to your otherwise impeccably behaved dog.

In many cases, the answer comes down to thresholds. Understanding your dog’s threshold in various situations is pivotal to being able to manage or improve their behavior. A dog’s threshold is the point at which they become too emotionally or physiologically aroused to respond to their environment in the way we would ideally like. Learning about thresholds helps us to recognize when our dog is capable of learning, and when we are asking too much.

Whether you are working with a reactive dog, an easily distracted puppy, an overexcited dog, or a dog that becomes uncomfortable around certain people or animals, understanding thresholds can help you train more effectively. Welcome to our deep-dive into the world of thresholds!

What does ‘threshold’ mean?

A threshold is essentially a point of tolerance. You’ve likely heard this in relation to humans – “they’ve reached the end of their threshold” when someone finally gets so frustrated or agitated in a certain scenario, and has a severe emotional reaction as a consequence.

Dogs can also reach the end of their threshold, or pass the threshold entirely. The level of threshold will vary, depending on the dog – taking into account factors such as their learned experiences, genetics, age, and other elements that can have an effect. A dog’s threshold is how easy – or difficult – it is to elicit a reaction in a dog from a wide variety of stimuli in their environment. A low-threshold dog reacts easily to stimuli, and a high-threshold dog is harder to elicit a reaction. In any given situation, your dog may hear a loud noise, see an unfamiliar dog, be part of a crowded environment, or become aware of a person approaching too quickly. Any or all of these may contribute to a growing level of arousal. A combination of these can often accelerate the speed toward passing threshold. 

When your dog reaches that point of passing threshold, their ability to process information and respond appropriately can change dramatically. This is why a dog that normally responds perfectly to “Sit” may suddenly appear unable to hear the cue when another dog is nearby. The problem isn’t that they have forgotten the behavior. It may not even be that they are distracted or unable to focus. It may simply be too far over threshold to perform the behavior successfully.

Thresholds are not just about aggression

The word “threshold” is often associated with reactive or aggressive dogs, but every dog has thresholds. Examples of everyday occurrences that can lead to your dog passing threshold include:

  • Seeing unfamiliar dogs
  • Meeting new people
  • Loud noises
  • Being handled
  • Excitement
  • Frustration
  • Environmental distractions
  • Separation from their owner
  • Resource guarding
  • Physical discomfort

The threshold will also vary depending on the situation. A dog that happily walks past another dog on a quiet street may struggle when walking through a busy park where dozens of dogs are present. The trigger is similar, but the overall level of stimulation is very different.

dogs thresholds

What happens when a dog goes over threshold?

When a dog becomes overwhelmed, their body begins responding to the situation as something that requires immediate attention. This can activate the sympathetic nervous system and produce a stress response commonly described as fight, flight, or freeze.

Once this happens, the dog may become intensely focused on whatever is causing the emotional response. Their ability to process other information can decrease significantly – it’s almost as if their ability to comprehend commands or instructions is blocked out by the enormity of the other triggers around them. During this, you might notice that your dog stares, stops responding to familiar commands, barks or growls, becomes excitable or agitated. The main consequence, however, is that they are unable to focus on you.

Dog owners sometimes interpret this as stubbornness or disobedience, but in reality, the dog may simply be overwhelmed. This is an important distinction because continuing to repeat commands when your dog is over threshold is unlikely to solve the problem.

Recognizing the signs beforehand

One of the most important skills an owner can develop is learning to identify what happens before their dog reaches threshold. The obvious reaction is usually not the beginning of the process. It is the culmination of it.

Dogs often provide subtle signals that their stress or arousal is increasing. Recognizing these body language signals is vital for understanding your dog’s reactions. The changes may be as subtle as a stiffening body posture, or as obvious as yawning, lip licking or panting. These signs can be easy to miss, particularly when owners are focused on the obvious trigger – but learning your dog’s individual body language allows you to intervene before the situation escalates.

Thresholds can change

It is particularly important to remember that puppies are learning about things out in the world, and all puppies go through a fear stage to one degree or another. This is a temporary phase in the dog’s development. It is this specific stage where people tend to overdo it or try to show their dog too much. It is important not to force the issue when a puppy is going through this stage. Sometimes, putting a microscope on the problem because a new puppy owner wants to fix it right away can only serve to make the problem worse. 

A dog’s threshold is not a fixed distance or a permanent number. A reactive dog might be able to calmly observe another dog from 100 feet away on one day but react at 150 feet on another. This is usually because the dog’s overall level of arousal may already be different on the second day – it is unlikely that everything in their world was exactly the same as the previous day. For example, they could have had a stressful morning, slept less than usual, encountered other distractions already, and so on.

This is sometimes referred to as trigger stacking. Trigger stacking is when multiple stressful (or even exciting) experiences can accumulate, until the dog has a reduced capacity to cope with the next one. Understanding this helps to explain why your dog’s behavior can sometimes appear inconsistent, even in seemingly identical situations.

Working under threshold

If your goal is to change a dog’s emotional response to a trigger, you generally want to work at a level where the dog can still think and learn. This is called keeping the dog under threshold.

For example, imagine that your dog reacts to other dogs at 30 feet away. At 30 feet, they may bark, lunge, and refuse food. Trying to train at 30 feet is probably too difficult.

At 75 feet, however, they might notice another dog, but remain able to look back at you and take a treat. That may be a much better training distance and is likely to produce better results.

The goal is not simply to keep the dog far away forever. Instead, you can gradually build the dog’s ability to remain calm and engaged as you systematically change the distance and difficulty. So you may begin at 75 feet, and then move to 65 feet, and then 55 feet, and so on. This process ensures that your dog can continue to make progress at the right speed – trying to move too quickly can undo a lot of good training. 

Thresholds and desensitization

Threshold management is particularly important when using behavior modification techniques such as desensitization and counterconditioning. Desensitization involves gradually exposing a dog to a trigger at an intensity they can handle, while counterconditioning works to change the dog’s emotional association with that trigger.

Neither process is likely to work well if the dog is repeatedly pushed into a full reaction if they breach their threshold. If your dog is barking and lunging every time they see another dog, they are practicing that response rather than learning a new one. Instead, successful behavior modification often involves carefully controlling the intensity of the trigger and rewarding appropriate responses while the dog remains capable of thinking.

What if your dog goes over their threshold?

Sometimes you cannot prevent a reaction, even with the best of intentions. You cannot completely control your dog’s environment – a dog may suddenly appear around a corner., someone may drop something loudly nearby, or another dog may unexpectedly run toward you. These are unfortunate but inevitable realities of taking your dog out in public. The key, however, is reacting calmly. 

The priority should always be safety and reducing the intensity of the situation. Create distance if possible. Move away from the trigger, change direction, or use environmental barriers to reduce your dog’s exposure. Once your dog is over threshold, you should place your training session on the backburner – your immediate goal should be helping them return to a calmer state of mind.

Raising your dog's threshold

With appropriate training, many dogs can gradually improve their ability to cope with triggers. This does not mean deliberately overwhelming the dog to ‘get them used to it’ – a process referred to as flooding. Flooding a dog with an overwhelming stimulus can increase fear, frustration, or reactivity.

Instead, build success gradually. Start at a level where your dog can remain calm or only mildly concerned. Reinforce appropriate behavior and gradually increase the difficulty as your dog demonstrates that they are ready. Progress may be slow at first, but small improvements matter. A dog that can calmly observe a trigger from 100 feet away may eventually be able to do so from 75 feet, then 50 feet, and eventually closer.

In conclusion

Understanding thresholds can change the way you look at your dog’s behavior – and result in better training outcomes.

Instead of asking, “Why won’t my dog listen?” you may start asking, “What happened before my dog stopped being able to listen?”

Recognizing your dog’s early signs of stress or arousal allows you to intervene before a reaction occurs. Keeping your dog under threshold gives them the opportunity to think, learn, and make better choices.

At K9 Evolutions Dog Training, we believe successful training starts with understanding the dog in front of you. By learning your dog’s thresholds and working at an appropriate level of difficulty, you can create more productive training sessions and help your dog develop the skills they need to navigate challenging situations with greater confidence. If you have questions about your dog’s behavior, reach out to us at (612) 227-7019 or email info@k9evolutionsdogtraining.com.

Leave a Reply